Other than being able to take an X240 inside it, and speeding things up if one is paying an outside installer to build a stack of inverters, in what manner is the PSAC superior to a plain old 200 A service entrance box for containing the AC side?
Also, I see somewhat conflicting statements about the FXA kit - mostly that it's code-essential except for inside the PSR (which "is available but undergoing a redesign"), but one forum post says that it's not really needed and simply provides more wiring space and a nicer cover? It's not exactly a trivial chunk of change if it's non-essential...
I can't say the PSR (such as I can find documentation on it) appeals much at all, so I guess the redesign is probably a good thing. Compact does not trump over sticking expensive electronics in close proximity to hydrogen and sulfuric acid for me - I like keeping in the battery in its own space.
Do I miss something about the PSAC (& FXA)
Moderators: OutBack Moderator Team, OutBack
Do I miss something about the PSAC (& FXA)
Cats, Coffee, Chocolate...Vices to Live By
-
Kent Osterberg
- Forum Emperor
- Posts: 1523
- Joined: Mon Jun 09, 2003 11:01 pm
- My RE system: SMA Sunny Boy 2500 with eight Mobil Solar Ra 180 modules
- Location: Cove, Oregon
- Contact:
If one were using a PSAC and a PSR, more than likely the PSR would only be used for batteries. That's what the PSR is best at. It is true that the conduit adapters aren't necessary if you put the inverter in the PSR. You will need at least the DCC and DCA for any installation where the inverter isn't contained in an enclosure.
You certainly can use a plain old 200A service panel rather than the PSAC and make a code compliant system while doing so. Depending on the options you need in your system, you could have a mess of things on the wall instead of the PSAC. The key word there is mess. If you need an X240, it'll need another enclosure. If you are going to have a generator in the system, you'll need to have another enclosure for a generator disconnect switch. A generator disconnect switch can only be avoided if the generator is adjacent to the inverter and includes another means, such as a plug, to disconnect it. If you want to have the option of running off of the generator in case the inverter fails, you'll need a transfer switch too. The PSAC makes for a clean looking installation.
By the way, in most installations you'll still need a service panel because the PSAC doesn't have room for enough circuits for most homes.
You certainly can use a plain old 200A service panel rather than the PSAC and make a code compliant system while doing so. Depending on the options you need in your system, you could have a mess of things on the wall instead of the PSAC. The key word there is mess. If you need an X240, it'll need another enclosure. If you are going to have a generator in the system, you'll need to have another enclosure for a generator disconnect switch. A generator disconnect switch can only be avoided if the generator is adjacent to the inverter and includes another means, such as a plug, to disconnect it. If you want to have the option of running off of the generator in case the inverter fails, you'll need a transfer switch too. The PSAC makes for a clean looking installation.
By the way, in most installations you'll still need a service panel because the PSAC doesn't have room for enough circuits for most homes.
Well, where would you use the FX inside the PSR then?
Could you put all the "stuff" inside the PSR (as one big-momma-enclosure) and delete the PSDC, PSAC, FXA, etc? Does the PSR have provision to mount all the breakers and controls on the outside of itself? I could see that as a viable alternative, but it's a bit hard to research at the moment as it's not in the catalog, so I have to depend on what I can find on retailer's web-sites, which mostly seem to be pushing it as a battery (or system with battery) enclosure. I'm just looking for the best-cost way to be code compliant...hmm - says one large DC breaker, so that makes it not likely for a system that might grow to 4 175A dc breakers. I wonder if my old HP equipment racks (19" racks) qualify as "rated" enclosures...
I'll indeed have other SE panels anyway, as I'm planning a "powershack" + Shop & House setup - And I had missed the integration of some "non-typical" features for a load center - though some can be done with a normal load center, too - ie, transfer switch without an extra box consists of two (or more ganged) properly interlocked side-by-side breakers rated for "backfeed" use.
I'm aiming for a 1 or 2 expandable to 4 VFX3648 setup - tenative (Outback) parts list looks somewhat like (buying various "quad" items at the outset, as being much less expensive in the long run than upgrading later):
VFX3648 (1 or possibly 2 to start, depending on other costs)
FXA kits
MX60
RTS
X240 (PSX240?)
Mate (read something about Mate2 being possibly a better enclosure?)
Hub10 (more money, more future expansion without throwing away a Hub 4)
PSPV
OBPV-2 breakers (if using weird/amorphous but cheap/available K60s)
Other breakers for other panel arrangements.
PS4DC-175
175A DC breaker(s)
60 / 70 A DC breakers (MX60 in/out)
OBDC-GFP/2 ?
PSAC-60Q
Could you put all the "stuff" inside the PSR (as one big-momma-enclosure) and delete the PSDC, PSAC, FXA, etc? Does the PSR have provision to mount all the breakers and controls on the outside of itself? I could see that as a viable alternative, but it's a bit hard to research at the moment as it's not in the catalog, so I have to depend on what I can find on retailer's web-sites, which mostly seem to be pushing it as a battery (or system with battery) enclosure. I'm just looking for the best-cost way to be code compliant...hmm - says one large DC breaker, so that makes it not likely for a system that might grow to 4 175A dc breakers. I wonder if my old HP equipment racks (19" racks) qualify as "rated" enclosures...
I'll indeed have other SE panels anyway, as I'm planning a "powershack" + Shop & House setup - And I had missed the integration of some "non-typical" features for a load center - though some can be done with a normal load center, too - ie, transfer switch without an extra box consists of two (or more ganged) properly interlocked side-by-side breakers rated for "backfeed" use.
I'm aiming for a 1 or 2 expandable to 4 VFX3648 setup - tenative (Outback) parts list looks somewhat like (buying various "quad" items at the outset, as being much less expensive in the long run than upgrading later):
VFX3648 (1 or possibly 2 to start, depending on other costs)
FXA kits
MX60
RTS
X240 (PSX240?)
Mate (read something about Mate2 being possibly a better enclosure?)
Hub10 (more money, more future expansion without throwing away a Hub 4)
PSPV
OBPV-2 breakers (if using weird/amorphous but cheap/available K60s)
Other breakers for other panel arrangements.
PS4DC-175
175A DC breaker(s)
60 / 70 A DC breakers (MX60 in/out)
OBDC-GFP/2 ?
PSAC-60Q
Cats, Coffee, Chocolate...Vices to Live By